Penryn heavy drinker beat girlfriend

A volatile relationship between two heavy drinkers culminated in Penryn man Wayne Hoare punching and kicking Abigail Bevis-Hole until she was unconscious, prosecutor Iain White has told Truro Crown Court.

A man without any previous convictions for violence, 40-year-old Hoare was living in Higher Market Street, until magistrates remanded him on bail to an address in Penzance after he had pleaded guilty to two offences of assault occasioning actual bodily harm.

Mr White said that both were alcohol dependent and had been drinking bourbon-whisky and cider on January 17 when they argued about money.

Hoare was in a rage when his computer was thrown against a wall and damaged, and he grabbed Ms Bevis-Hole by the throat and held her down on the floor, punching and kicking her in the head.

Defending, Curtis Lewis described it as an appalling incident which Hoare greatly regretted, and Judge Christopher Harvey Clark QC agreed he should be absolutely ashamed of what he had done.

“I am entirely satisfied that at the root of your conduct was your drinking,” he said.

Hoare was given an eight-month prison sentence, suspended for two years, with supervision.

He must receive alcohol treatment for six months and attend 29 sessions of the Building Better Relationships programme.

Hoare must also pay a £100 victim surcharge.

Comments(4)

Gillian Zella Martin 09 says...
10:01am Mon 4 Mar 13

If anyone can claim as a defence that alcohol was the cause of any violent behaviour, then should alcohol not have a warning printed on the bottle/can stating that if drunk in excess it may make one violent, much the same way that tobacco has to have a warning about health risks. What is to stop me having a drink of orange/lemonade etc and hitting someone and saying, well sorry but that orange juice just made me feel violent because of the excess energy suddenly incurred by the sugar content., who can prove that the alcohol is what changes someones personality and that they would not be viloent without alcohol. What about car-park ticket machines I may get violent after I see the price of the car-park ticket, then could I claim that my violence was induced under exceptional circumstances.

Gillian Zella Martin 09 says...
10:04am Mon 4 Mar 13

Last post should read violent without alcohol not viloent.

ucsweb says...
9:22am Tue 5 Mar 13

In the same way that all cars should have "Exhaust may damage your health" down the side and all water should have "Risk of drowning"?

Gillian Zella Martin 09 says...
12:10pm Tue 5 Mar 13

My point was, I don't think anyone should be able to use alcohol as a defence for being violent. In many cases a judge appears to accept that alcohol was the cause of someone's behaviour, as in the above article. Therefore if I assault someone can I then claim I was drunk at the time and receive a lighter sentence. I believe if someone who has been drinking alcohol assaults someone, then the sentence/punishment should be the same as if they had committed an assault whilst sober. Otherwise, in my view it is a 'get out' clause.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree