Porthleven fishermen count the cost of storm chaos

Porthleven fishermen Wayne Ward, Mike Perkins, Nigel Pepperell and Jonathan Fletcher were among those helping to pull all the boats from the harbour

Porthleven fishermen Wayne Ward, Mike Perkins, Nigel Pepperell and Jonathan Fletcher were among those helping to pull all the boats from the harbour

First published in News Exclusive by , News Editor

Fishermen battled to save their livelihoods last week when Porthleven’s sea defences crumbled – causing the loss of ten boats.

The eight balks (giant pieces of wood) meant to protect the inner harbour from the main brunt of the sea were entirely washed away, resulting in huge waves rolling into the normally protected waters.

It led to the 40 boats taking shelter in the inner harbour to be “tossed around like toys” according to one eyewitness.

Ten sunk, with three of them a total loss.

The entire community moved quickly to save the other boats from the clutches on the sea, with the fishermen joined by farmers and owners of 4x4 vehicles.

One farmer travelled from Leedstown to help, while plumbers brought their vans and one taxi driver even used his personal car.

A large crane pulled large boats out, with a smaller crane also in use while the water was it the harbour.

Once the tide went out tractors and vehicles were used to pull out the smaller vessels.

Harbourmaster Phil Ward said: “Thank you to everybody that turned out and helped to get the boats out – especially the farmers and people with 4x4s. There were probably 100 people down there through the day.”

He described the situation as “heartbreaking” for all involved, adding: “You sit there and watch your boat, and think you can’t do anything about it.

“I wouldn’t let anybody out there – I couldn’t afford to lose a life out of it. You can always replace a boat, not a life.”

Mr Ward said he had never seen such push behind the waves, which led to 18 inches of water coming over the edge of the harbour, above quay level.

David Toy, skipper owner of the Sheila T, was one of the lucky ones. He had been doing a refit on his boat, which meant she was already on dry land – although that almost didn’t save her, as the force of the waves meant she only narrowly avoided being floated off the edge of the harbour.

Despite this, he has still lost hundreds of pounds worth of equipment that were washed to the bottom of the harbour.

Mr Toy, who is currently working on deep sea trawlers, but has fished out of Porthleven full time for the last seven years, said: “I’m fortunate that I’ve got my boat, but I’ve lost about £700 in ropes and buoys and nets.

“I’ve been here all my life and although I’ve seen seas the same, not the storm surge.”

He described coming off the back of the spring tide, rather than immediately during it, was their “saving grace” – a few days earlier and the story could have been very different.

As it was ten boats were lost to the water, although none belonging to the five fishermen that count on the sea as their livelihood.

However, Gary Eastwell, one of the fulltime commercial fishermen, came close, with the sea washing into a normally protected quay.

“We’ve been lucky, in a sense, here – it could have been a lot worse,” added Mr Toy.

Another of the fishermen, Jonathan Fletcher from Ruan Minor, admitted that initially he feared the worst for his vessel the St Ruan.

“When I was phoned and told the baulks had gone I thought, ‘That will be it. It will be sunk.’ But I must have been in a lucky spot – it hung on. I’ve got superficial damage and that’s all,” he said.

The Porthleven Fishermen’s Association is now collecting for the fishermen who have lost out financially – in particular for the cost of lifting their boats out the harbour, which they covered themselves.

To help with the cause the Atlantic Inn in Porthleven is holding a day of fundraising this Saturday (February 15) with a coffee morning at 10.30am to include a raffle.

Then, from 8pm, there will be bingo, with prizes donated by businesses in the area, and entertainment provided by local musician Bob Seymour.

During the interval an auction of more valuable prizes will take place, together with a raffle stocked again by local businesses.

Also for the association, Skinners Brewery is offering to donate 5p from every pint of its beer ‘Porthleven’ sold across February to the Fisherman’s Association.

Falmouth pub The Boathouse has already given a £750 donation.

Falmouth Packet:

 David Toy feared his boat the Sheila T would float over the wall into the harbour due to the force of the waves.

 

Comments (6)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

5:10pm Thu 13 Feb 14

Gillian R.Z. Martin says...

I am really pleased everyone was safe and sympathise with those fishermen and everyone who has suffered financially, I hope the fundraising does really well, they deserve support in their time of need.
I am really pleased everyone was safe and sympathise with those fishermen and everyone who has suffered financially, I hope the fundraising does really well, they deserve support in their time of need. Gillian R.Z. Martin
  • Score: 3

8:03am Sun 16 Feb 14

Cyber Pasty says...

Do they not have insurance on their boats and contents?
Do they not have insurance on their boats and contents? Cyber Pasty
  • Score: 1

9:46am Sun 16 Feb 14

Gillian R.Z. Martin says...

Many boats used regularly for fishing are virtually uninsurable. Its a bit like asking an insurance company to insure you if you live right on the edge of a crumbling cliff. The cost would be so high many people could not afford it even if they found a firm willing to insure.
Many boats used regularly for fishing are virtually uninsurable. Its a bit like asking an insurance company to insure you if you live right on the edge of a crumbling cliff. The cost would be so high many people could not afford it even if they found a firm willing to insure. Gillian R.Z. Martin
  • Score: 1

6:01pm Sun 16 Feb 14

Cyber Pasty says...

Haha I love my thumbs down. I did not know that. Well Nick Gleggy Clegg has a magical pot of gold to pay for everything to be replaced anyway.
Haha I love my thumbs down. I did not know that. Well Nick Gleggy Clegg has a magical pot of gold to pay for everything to be replaced anyway. Cyber Pasty
  • Score: 1

6:31pm Sun 16 Feb 14

Gillian R.Z. Martin says...

Cyber Pasty wrote:
Haha I love my thumbs down. I did not know that. Well Nick Gleggy Clegg has a magical pot of gold to pay for everything to be replaced anyway.
I actually thumbed your comment up as I thought it was a perfectly valid question. I think it is wrong to thumb down people for asking questions.
That is funny about the pot of gold, I will be interested to see how much in the end Cornwall does actually receive from the government.
[quote][p][bold]Cyber Pasty[/bold] wrote: Haha I love my thumbs down. I did not know that. Well Nick Gleggy Clegg has a magical pot of gold to pay for everything to be replaced anyway.[/p][/quote]I actually thumbed your comment up as I thought it was a perfectly valid question. I think it is wrong to thumb down people for asking questions. That is funny about the pot of gold, I will be interested to see how much in the end Cornwall does actually receive from the government. Gillian R.Z. Martin
  • Score: 2

8:30pm Sun 16 Feb 14

Cyber Pasty says...

GZM has my back :D
GZM has my back :D Cyber Pasty
  • Score: 1

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree