'Banana republic' ban on Falmouth petition signing against council's privatisation plan
12:30pm Friday 21st September 2012 in News By Jonathan Millar
One of the organisers of a bid by Labour Party members in Falmouth to collect signatures for the cross party petition opposing the privatisation of Cornwall Council services has hit out at a decision to stop them.
Calling the decision, which organisers claim followed a conversation with the Falmouth town clerk, like something from a "banana republic rather than Cornwall", Cornwall Labour chair and Falmouth resident Candy Atherton said it smacked of some petty bureaucrat in County Hall wanting to stop politicians and political parties talking to people.
The petition was to be at The Moor on Saturday between 2 - 4pm.
Last week, despite the majority of councillors voting against the proposal. the Conservative and Independent members who make up the leadership announced they would proceed regardless.
The majority of councillors, who oppose the policy, have launched a petition calling for the decision to be stopped until the majority of all councillors have voted to support.
Cornwall Labour chair and Falmouth resident Candy Atherton said they have now been told that the petition signing cannot go ahead.
She said: I am surprised and disappointed that the long tradition of political engagement in our town has been stopped. I have many pictures of successful stalls which my party have held on
The Moor and know that the local Labour Party have been regularly seen running stalls in the town for nearly a century.
"In the spirit of supporting the town the Falmouth Labour Party decided to apply for a stall and pay so as to be on the same basis as other stallholders. To be told we are not allowed is
plain wrong. Democratic political parties are part of the community of a town.
"People say they never see politicians until elections well this is hardly surprising if they are banned from the centre of town where they can be challenged on their policies and held to account.
"In a democratic and pluralist society banning political parties rather smacks of some petty bureaucrat in County Hall wanting to stop politicians and political parties talking to people. Sounds like something from a banana republic rather than Cornwall."
Comments(11)
Gill Zella Martin
says...
4:28pm Thu 13 Sep 12
DCI Jen
says...
10:29pm Fri 14 Sep 12
Gill Zella Martin
says...
11:15am Sat 15 Sep 12
Falmouthboy
says...
12:40pm Mon 17 Sep 12
DCI Jen
says...
1:13pm Mon 17 Sep 12
Gill Zella Martin
says...
3:40pm Mon 17 Sep 12
Glad to see that the petition initiated by Cllr Andrew Wallis against privatization has gained great support and I feel sure it will continue to do so.
The railways and the water companies were privatized and that has seen an increase in cost to the public and in the case of a certain rail operating company it was a complete disaster.
ucsweb
says...
1:09pm Tue 18 Sep 12
Otherwise we could be facing this problem again in the future. I still don't understand how an elected body can create an inner dictatorship to control them.
Gill Zella Martin
says...
3:54pm Tue 18 Sep 12
Felix DuCat
says...
7:18pm Sun 23 Sep 12
On Saturday the 16th the Falmouth Labour party went to the Moor to collect signatures for the anti service cuts proposed by Cornwall Council. Around 200 names were collected and this was deemed a success. The Falmouth Labour party considered that a regular presents on the Moor would be a good idea to promote its aims and activity’s The appropriate authority’s were approached to rent a stall on the Moor once a month. We we politely told by Falmouth‘s town Clark that this was not possible as the County Council had banned all political party’s from using the Moor for political activity’s.
I don’t know when the County Council enacted this rule came in to ban democratic political party’s pursuing legitimate public debate and campaigning. This decision is anti-democratic, foolish, and just plane wrong. Its bad enough that Cornwall Council,s Cabinet is ramrodding It’s privatization policy on to the people of Cornwall. Now they have ban legitimate political assembly in a prominent public place where people can meet with party activists and debate with them. This is where grievance’s are aired. views are exchanged., and maybe the odd harsh word exchanged for good measure. This is the body politic at work. Now we find that Cornwall council has banned the right of democratic political assembly. It’s is the sort of thing a Banana republic would stoop to. But that’s what we have come to expect from Cornwall Council now.
Teejay
says...
9:38am Wed 26 Sep 12
The council can make rules for the conduct of members in their council work, but surely they're also permitted free speech and personal views outside of chambers.

Gill Zella Martin says...
4:24pm Thu 13 Sep 12
As I have previously said, why when they held a vote to investigate a business plan for the stadium and it was democratically voted against, did they not ignore democracy then and go ahead regardless? Mr Robertson should explain the difference. Either he believes in democracy or he does not. Someone 'please explain'