Battle of the council tax freeze budgets at County Hall

First published in Truro
Last updated

The battle of the budgets is continuing at County Hall, as the two main political parties at the authority push to freeze council tax for the coming year.

According to the chief finance officer, the Lib Dem plan is said to satisfy "the essential requirement of an amendment to the budget in that the savings recommended address the whole budget shortfall arising from a no increase in the council tax".

However concerns remain about where the axe will fall if it is accepted.

The same officer said that the Conservative plan simply did not add up, saying: "This proposal does not satisfy for an essential amendment to the budget in that it fails to deliver a medium term sustainable budget strategy”

One councillor, Andrew Wallis (Ind, Helston South and Porthleven) is warning that if this ammendment is accepted there will be more job loses and services the council provides will be reduced, or stopped completely.

While both sides are pushing for a zero per cent rise, even for the very wealthiest people in Cornwall, the authority has just voted to make the very poorest in Cornwall pay council tax.

This has led to claims that the freeze is little more than a bid to gain positive headlines in advance of the local government elections in May, with cllr Wallis saying both budget amendments were "more about election headlines, than a sensible budget, which will protect services".

He said: "Everyone wants low Council Tax bills and good services. And in an ideal world, the council should be able to set a zero per cent budget.

"But it is not an ideal world, the financial pressures are massive, which have been made worse by the very party in Government this amendment comes from. Even worse, MPs are putting pressure on people to have a zero per cent budget, so they and their party look good too.

"I say to them, concentrate on your own house, before you tell Cornwall Council what to do.

"For me, I do not mind paying an extra £25 or so per year because services will be protected if an increase of 1.97 per cent is implemented. We have had two-years of no increase. So it has not all been doom and gloom.

"The very same party [Conservative] behind this amendment has made the poorest and most in need pay 25 per cent, or over £300 extra, per year. But seem happy to push for a zero per cent increase even though it will make services worse."

Read what the council's own expert officer said about the two plans.

The Lib Dem amendment:

Falmouth Packet: LD1

Falmouth Packet: LD

Falmouth Packet: LD3

The Conservative amendment:

Falmouth Packet: T1

Falmouth Packet: T2

Falmouth Packet: T3

Falmouth Packet: T4

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

7:22pm Mon 25 Feb 13

Gillian Zella Martin 09 says...

I don't think the Lib Dems know what they are talking about because originally some tried to argue against making the poorest pay council tax by saying it would prove difficult to collect the money from people in the poorest category, now some have said they need to increase the rate of collection success of council tax from eveyone so that will generate more income, is that not a little contradictory. As for the Conservatives, their budget appears to me little more than an electioneering campaign, they cannot even seem to agree amongst their own party.

This is a perfect example why in my view politics should be taken out of the running of Cornwall Council and indeed town councils, there is no place for a political agenda in the council if the best results for Cornwall are to be achieved.
I don't think the Lib Dems know what they are talking about because originally some tried to argue against making the poorest pay council tax by saying it would prove difficult to collect the money from people in the poorest category, now some have said they need to increase the rate of collection success of council tax from eveyone so that will generate more income, is that not a little contradictory. As for the Conservatives, their budget appears to me little more than an electioneering campaign, they cannot even seem to agree amongst their own party. This is a perfect example why in my view politics should be taken out of the running of Cornwall Council and indeed town councils, there is no place for a political agenda in the council if the best results for Cornwall are to be achieved. Gillian Zella Martin 09
  • Score: 0

1:03am Tue 26 Feb 13

Wave says...

I wonder how different things would be if all the money Cornwall generated stayed in Cornwall. But no money came from UK government.
I wonder how different things would be if all the money Cornwall generated stayed in Cornwall. But no money came from UK government. Wave
  • Score: 0

7:48am Tue 26 Feb 13

Gillian Zella Martin 09 says...

Wave wrote:
I wonder how different things would be if all the money Cornwall generated stayed in Cornwall. But no money came from UK government.
I doubt Cornwall would survive without UK government money.
I believe Cornwall Council would benefit though from a larger percentage of truly Independent Councillors, that way they may concentrate more on working together for the good of Cornwall instead of all this electioneering that is currently going on and trying to please their political parties and In turn Westminster, while they are busy with all the political infighting nothing much in my view is being achieved. I would like to see cabinet system changed to committee or hybrid and have independent members included in it.
[quote][p][bold]Wave[/bold] wrote: I wonder how different things would be if all the money Cornwall generated stayed in Cornwall. But no money came from UK government.[/p][/quote]I doubt Cornwall would survive without UK government money. I believe Cornwall Council would benefit though from a larger percentage of truly Independent Councillors, that way they may concentrate more on working together for the good of Cornwall instead of all this electioneering that is currently going on and trying to please their political parties and In turn Westminster, while they are busy with all the political infighting nothing much in my view is being achieved. I would like to see cabinet system changed to committee or hybrid and have independent members included in it. Gillian Zella Martin 09
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree