Mylor parish councillor accused of holocaust denial censured

Cllr Lawrence, far left, attended the extraordinary meeting of Mylor Parish Council <i>(Image: Staff)</i>
Cllr Lawrence, far left, attended the extraordinary meeting of Mylor Parish Council (Image: Staff)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A Mylor Bridge parish councillor accused of holocaust denial has refused to resign despite being censured for his views by his own council.

At a packed extraordinary meeting of Mylor Parish Council last night, councillors voted on whether to support a motion brought by Cllrs Patrick Polglaze and Paul Baker that asserted that the views of Cllr Peter Lawrence were deeply insulting and offensive to the memory of all those who lost their lives in the war.

The motion said that the claims by Cllr Lawrence, who represents the British Democratic Party, that Hitler had “no beef” with the Jews and were responsible for starting World War Two had brought the name of the council and its councillors into disrepute.

It said: “To make such assertions regarding a truly horrific time in our history is deeply insulting and offensive to the memory of all those who lost their lives, and their families and is not something that the parish council would ever wish to be thought of as in agreement with.”

Cllr Lawrence was filmed in Truro being asked if he thought anti-semitism existedCllr Lawrence was filmed in Truro being asked if he thought anti-semitism existed (Image: Cornwall Resists/Facebook)

It said that the council unequivocally rejected the comments made by Cllr Lawrence at a far right organised so called general strike in Truro last month.

At the rally on Lemon Quay, with a backdrop of people draped in Union Jack flags, Cllr Lawrence was filmed by anti-fascist protestors from Cornwall Resists saying that “technically” antisemitism didn’t exist.

The group accused Cllr Lawrence of being an antisemite and a holocaust denier over the deaths of six million Jews during World War Two at the hands of the Nazis in death camps.

Prior to councillors voting on the motion, members of the public were given the chance to have their say on the matter.

Former parish councillor Michael Wilmore said councillors must be accountable for their actions to the public and Cllr Lawrence had embarrassed the council and should do the honourable thing and resign.

People gathered at the start of the meeting. More supporters of Cllr Lawrence arrived shortly after this picture was taken and stood at the backPeople gathered at the start of the meeting. More supporters of Cllr Lawrence arrived shortly after this picture was taken and stood at the back (Image: Staff)

Another Mylor resident said she didn’t know Cllr Lawrence, but she found his comments “absolutely abhorrent”.

She said his views, “which he had recently doubled down on”, surely brought the reputation of the council into disrepute.

She said the British Democrat Party was a far-right party that had come from the British National Party which itself had come from the National Front.

She said he could not truly claim to represent the people of Mylor with that political stance when he was only elected by default. She said parish councils were generally non-political.

“His public allegiance BDP and its attempt to make political capital from his public role further brings our parish council into disrepute,” she said. She said she thought he should resign and was not a fit representative.

A younger member of the audience who said he had only moved to the village six months ago said he had been shocked by the comments of Cllr Lawrence.

He said to hear an elected representative of the place he lived disputing the horrors of the Third Reich was frankly “terrifying”.

Cllr Lawrence, left, listens to what is being saidCllr Lawrence, left, listens to what is being said (Image: Staff)

“It honestly makes me wonder whether I should leave,” he said. “As a young person, if that’s the kind of person you have on this council and if he doesn’t stand down why should I feel safe in this community anymore?”

Despite most people attending the meeting supporting the motion, there was a significant number, at least six, in support of Cllr Lawrence.

One attendee, who said he was from Mylor, claimed that he was from a Jewish family that on his mother’s side had been killed by Ukrainians not the Nazis. He said that he thought it was a witch hunt against Cllr Lawrence.

This was applauded enthusiastically by at least six members of the audience, although it wasn’t clear whether they were from Mylor or had come in from elsewhere.

But another Jewish woman told the meeting that it was the Ukrainian Fascists that had killed the Jews.

“You could make the link there to Mr Lawrence’s allegiance to the British Democratic Party,” she said.

Other supporters claimed that Cllr Lawrence was just exercising his right to free speech.

But the former director of Falmouth Maritime Museum Jonathan Griffin said it wasn’t a question of freedom of speech it was a question of who’s representing the community on the parish council.

“Someone who is in denial of the facts of three major issues: the holocaust, antisemitism and climate change I do not find it credible that they can represent me and represent the community of Mylor or the parish council when he is in denial of the facts and takes such a cavalier attitude, he not the right person to be making decisions in the parish.”


READ NEXT:

'Controlling' man now on 'very narrow ledge' with suspended sentence

Park and Ride to run shuttle service to city for Truro Classic Car Show

Person trapped in cove found by lifeboats after they spotted mobile phone light


Chairman Cllr John Symons told the meeting that the council had received many complaints about Cllr Lawrence’s remarks, but it did not have the power to dismiss a councillor.

If anyone thought Cllr Lawrence had breached the code of conduct, they should contact the monitoring officer at Cornwall Council, he said.

Prior to the vote being taken Cllr Lawrence made a statement saying he had no intention of resigning.

He offered an apology to the council for the inconvenience and the time it had taken up. He said he was not at the strike representing Mylor Parish Council and what he’d been filmed saying had been “poorly articulated” and could have been misinterpreted and seen to be disrespectful “by some”. He claimed that the reporting had been “severely biased”.

He said it was not his intention for any of his words to cause offence, but he rejected the claim he was an antisemite or holocaust denier.

All councillors, except for Cllr Lawrence who abstained, voted to support the motion.

 

 

 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos