St Ives Premier Inn plan protest taken to Angela Rayner

Campaigners Michelle Curnow, Brian Selman and Shelley Thornton take their Premier Inn battle to Westminster (Pic: Courtesy of Shelley Thornton)
Campaigners Michelle Curnow, Brian Selman and Shelley Thornton take their Premier Inn battle to Westminster (Pic: Courtesy of Shelley Thornton)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.
Close Icon

Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.

Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?

What is the Public Notice Portal?

The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.

Search the Public Notice Portal

Residents who are livid that a controversial plan to build a Premier Inn in their Cornish town was allowed on appeal by a government inspector have taken their fight direct to the office of Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner, writes Local Democracy Reporter Lee Trewhela.

They have the support of their local MP who has asked Ms Rayner to reverse the decision.

The saga of Whitbread’s plan to build a 90-room Premier Inn overlooking St Ives has played out over the past two years. Hundreds of locals opposed the plan to demolish a Cornwallis care home on Trewidden Road and replace it with the hotel, which has previously been dubbed a “monstrosity” and “far too big and ugly”.

St Ives Town Council was also against the proposal, which was refused by a Cornwall Council planning committee in April 2024 on the grounds of harm to the character and appearance of the area. However, planning inspector Sylvia Leonard approved the proposal last month following an appeal by Whitbread.

She stated that the Premier Inn “would not appear as unduly visually prominent or discordant within the hillside setting of the town and would not harm the setting of the conservation area”. Members of a campaign group representing the 600 people who originally opposed the application have not taken the decision lying down.

They made the 600-mile round-trip from St Ives to Westminster this week to take their protest to the Deputy PM’s door and handed her office a letter asking that she quashes the appeal decision. Leading campaigner Shelley Thornton said: “We think it went pretty well. We got in front of one of Angela Rayner’s parliamentary private secretaries, handed her the letter and case file, and talked through some key issues.

“We remain confident that this is an exceptional case and the evidence is there to quash this decision and do it correctly. We believe she understood why we have gone this route and not a judicial review. We pointed out the procedural unfairness in the process as well as pointing her to the three fundamental errors of judgement.”

The three ‘fundamental errors’ they cite are “the inspector’s subjective assessment of the size and scale of the chain hotel and its impact on the town”, the inspector’s “unfathomable” assessment of the location of the hotel as a “gateway site” into St Ives and the loss of St Ives’ last care home.


READ NEXT:

New all-weather family attraction set for Cornwall holiday park

Sex offender sentenced after being found guilty of abuse of two young boys. 


St Ives’ Liberal Democrat MP Andrew George arranged the visit yesterday (Wednesday, June 25). He said: “I support St Ives campaigners who are challenging the inappropriate development of its last remaining care home. The planning proposal is clearly contrary to the very carefully prepared St Ives Neighbourhood Development Plan. Its size, scale, location and impact on the adjoining neighbourhood are not supported by NDP policies.

“There is insufficient infrastructure, including limited and highly contested parking spaces within the area. The location does not lend itself to adequately accommodate such a proposal.

“St Ives has become overly dependent on tourism. There are few facilities – including care homes – available for local people and the housing market operates almost as if locals shouldn’t live there anyway. For me, it’s an important matter of principle, that local communities which have carefully drawn up plans within the national planning policy framework should have their planning policies respected, and not blithely overridden as they have been in this case.

“I’m asking the DPM to use her ‘call-in’ powers. Though she would effectively be ‘calling-in’ her own decision, it would be justified on the basis that it appears she may have been misled by her inspector.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos