A councillor accused of spouting “vile, anti-Semitic rubbish” did not breach the code of conduct despite hundreds of complaints about his outburst.
Mylor parish councillor Peter Lawrence, who is a member of the far-right British Democratic Party, made international headlines in June when protest group Cornwall Resists filmed him at a rally in Truro saying the Holocaust was “massively over-exaggerated”.
The founder of the Farmers Movement Cornwall campaign group was asked if antisemitism exists and he replied “technically, no”. He then went on to say, “Hitler did not have a beef with the Jews” and claimed the Jewish people were responsible for starting the Second World War.
He was censured by his own parish council for bringing his fellow councillors and Mylor council into disrepute by association. He refused to resign but did apologise to fellow members.
Cornwall Council revealed it had received more than 100 complaints regarding Cllr Lawrence’s conduct, with the unitary authority reporting his remarks to the police.
However, Devon and Cornwall Police said that no further action would be taken.
Following the complaints about the councillor’s behaviour the monitoring officer at Cornwall Council found there had been no breach of the Code of Conduct because he was not acting in his capacity as a councillor and didn’t claim to be.
It said because of this no further action could be taken.
The officer said a large number of complaints had been received, well in excess of 130, against Cllr Lawrence.
He said some complaints were received from history students, some from members of the Jewish community, with several of these elderly, and all set out that they consider that the answers given to those questions by Cllr Lawrence were strongly indicative of Holocaust denialism, “in a manner that is completely ahistorical and damages the reputation of Mylor Parish Council”.
Several of the complainants have also raised the point that Lawrence was not elected,.
The report says when asked what Hitler’s problem with the Jewish people were, “Cllr Lawrence employed many extreme anti-Jewish sentiments in his explanation, including those used by the Nazi party in the lead up to and during the Holocaust.
“The Subject Member’s answer was that ‘The world Jewry declared war on Germany. They were bankrupting them from the treaty of Versailles, they were blocking their food and everything, they were starving them out. The Jews, who are communist, were responsible for a lot of problems in the Weimar republic, were frustrating the efforts of the restoration of the German people to have self-determination and to be ruled by the Germans. So, Hitler actually had no - Hitler didn’t have beef with the Jews. He just didn’t want them to disrupt what was going on, and they continued to do so’.
“After this the Subject Member was asked if he thought ‘Hitler was right to kill so many Jews?’ To this, he responded that, ‘I, and from what I’ve read, the revisionist historians that I’ve read, cannot find a single order from Adolf Hitler calling for the execution of the Jews. So, if you believe in the Holocaust, the Holocaust has been massively exaggerated’.”
Several complainants linked the statements to online posts made by Cllr Lawrence where he advocates policies that prioritise financial benefits and national belonging based explicitly on a person’s “majority European genetic makeup” and multi-generational ancestry in Britain.
He also claims that mixed-race individuals (specifically those of non-European heritage) would not qualify for support under his proposed policies, as they do not fit his vision of national identity rooted in “blood, soil and faith.”
“These views bear a chilling resemblance to language used in fascist and white supremacist ideologies, including direct echoes of Nazi terminology such as “blood and soil,” which was central to the racist ideology of the Third Reich and are said by the Complainants to be incompatible with the values of equality, inclusion, and human dignity that are protected under UK law and public office standards,” said the report.
“In some of the complaints it is noted that, while the Subject Member may not have been acting in a strictly public capacity, the Subject Member made these comments to members of the public who were clearly aware of his position on the Council.
“In the past, “revisionist historians” who question the historical facts of the Holocaust, such as David Irving, have been successfully prosecuted and jailed under UK law. Mr Irving also argued that Hitler did not give the orders for the Holocaust. Allowing a sitting member of the council to publicly espouse views like these without question throws the council into disrepute, especially in the eyes of the local Jewish community.”
It said while people who complained supported free speech, they said people have been prosecuted for denying the holocaust in the past.
It said in his response Cllr Lawrence sent the monitoring officer seven pages of documents seeking to justify his stance.
The monitoring officer said while this was read and noted it did not deserve the oxygen of further publicity other than what was necessary for the assessment of the complaint.
He denied any intent to commit ‘hate speech’ or that what he has said constituted “hate speech”.
He made it clear that he attended the event as a member of the public and not as a councillor and believed there was no disrepute by association.
In the officer’s opinion, while Cllr Lawrence had made an error in personal judgement by airing his controversial and unpopular views in public, he was not acting as a councillor.
Read more
It said despite there not being a contested election, Cllr Lawrence had been ‘elected’ to the post.
Prior to 2006 a councillor was bound by the Code 24 hours a day. However, this was then challenged in the courts and case law at the time set out that there was to be a distinction between the person and the office.
“I have reviewed all of the complaints which have been submitted, and there is nothing to indicate that the Subject Member was in attendance in Truro as a Mylor parish councillor or that he spoke as a councillor, or by some other means gave the impression he was acting as a Councillor whilst speaking,” said the officer.
It said therefore, the only finding which can be made at assessment is one of no breach of the Code of Conduct.
In conclusion they said: “However, it should be noted that the findings in this Notice should not be taken as this process supporting the views of the Subject Member in any form whatsoever, and to reiterate, it is only the limitations of the regime which prevents it from being further considered.”
Share