Council cancelled plans fell trees Trelawney Road, Falmouth

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Cornwall Council has scrapped its controversial plans to fell three protected trees next month following months of public protests and mounting pressure from campaign group Stop the Chop! and Falmouth Town Council.

The chopping down the three lime trees in Trelawney Road, Falmouth, was due to take place from November 17. That is now not happening. It is not known whether the work will take place on another date.

The decision, announced after recent meetings between the parties, marks a temporary reprieve for the trees, which have become a symbol of local resistance to opaque decision-making. However, campaigners say the council has yet to provide any clear justification for the proposed felling, leaving campaigners and residents demanding answers.

The trees in Trelawney Road the council want to chop down(Image: Stop the Chop)

A spokesperson for Stop the Chop! said: “This is great news in the short term at least. We’ve been asking why the trees need to be felled for over nine months and had to experience three public protests, two with the police threatening to arrest people, in order to show our concern about due process.”

The group had formally asked Cornwall Council to provide verifiable evidence that justified the removal of the trees, which are widely believed to be healthy and structurally sound. Instead, campaigners claim the council admitted that the felling was not due to uneven pavements or damaged utilities but was linked to an out-of-court settlement with a third-party property owner.

That settlement, reportedly worth over £100,000, includes a confidentiality clause that prevents disclosure of the evidence behind the decision. This has sparked outrage among campaigners and councillors alike.

“In the case of the Trelawney Trees the cat is well and truly out of the bag,” said a campaign spokesperson. “If the three trees are causing damage to a property, it's time all parties involved in the out-of-court settlement came clean and let the public know what’s going on. Where’s the evidence that justifies felling the three Trelawney trees … assuming there is some?”

Freedom of Information requests submitted by Stop the Chop! have been refused, with Cornwall Council citing concerns that disclosure could “adversely affect international relations, defence, national security or public safety”—a response campaigners have called “crazy” and “top secret obviously.”

Falmouth Town Council has also expressed concern, stating it was misled into believing the trees posed a danger. The revelation that the felling was part of a confidential legal agreement has raised broader questions about how many other trees may have been removed under similar circumstances.

Campaigners warn that this sets a dangerous precedent for urban tree management, where public assets could be sacrificed behind closed doors without scrutiny or accountability.

As the November felling date is scrapped, the future of the Trelawney Trees remains uncertain.

Cornwall Council has been asked for a response.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos