Cornwall farmer in court for asbestos rubble dumped on land

Material dumped on the farm land included asbestos. File image. <i>(Image: Getty Images/iStockphoto)</i>
Material dumped on the farm land included asbestos. File image. (Image: Getty Images/iStockphoto)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A farmer in Cornwall must pay almost £90,000 after he “turned a blind eye” to 10,000 tonnes of rubble being dumped on his land – which it transpired contained asbestos.

Before Truro Crown Court for sentencing on Friday was Martin Harvey.

The 64-year-old previously admitted two environmental offences on his land at St Newlyn East, carried out between October 20, 2021 and February 23, 2023.

The first of two charges brought by the Environment Agency was that he operated a regulated facility, namely a waste operation, including the deposit and storage of controlled waste on his land, other than under and to the extent authorised by an environmental permit.

The second was that he disposed of controlled waste, namely material containing asbestos, in a manner likely to cause pollution of the environment or harm to human health.

The court was told that in a bid to bring in extra income to the farm, Harvey came up with a plan to building a shooting range.

To fill an area to flatten off for hardstanding, he put the word out that there was an opportunity for hauliers to move rubble onto his land.

This led to around 10,000 tonnes of waste and rubble, including building rubble, being dumped – causing “considerable damage” to the environment, not least because what was left contained asbestos.

Judge Simon Carr said Harvey had been “reckless” in his actions, which amounted to “turning a blind eye” to the amount of material appearing on his land – in particular the building waste, which could, and did, contain dangerous materials.

The presence of asbestos meant that the offence passed the custody threshold “because asbestos kills people.”

However, the judge said mitigating that was the large amount of work already carried out by Harvey to clear the land and remedy the problem, which meant he could take an unusual step in such cases, of suspending the sentence.

He accepted that Harvey was unaware that the material contained asbestos, despite it being dumped in blue bags, but said: “The risk was there, because building rubble is an ideal target for people willing to break the law.”

The court was told that the haulier companies dumping the waste of Harvey’s land had since gone bust.

Defence barrister Nicholas Cotter, representing Harvey, reiterated his lack of knowledge of what the rubble contained, adding: “It has plagued Mr Harvey that people think he would deliberately damage his own land.”

Sentencing Harvey, Judge Carr said: “The circumstances are as sad as they are serious.

“You are now a farmer in your 60s, who has farmed your whole life. Everything I’ve read about you, except from these offences, is that you are a conscientious farmer keen to do well.

“Farmers on paper are capital rich, but income poor. In order to achieve a meeting of the circle farmers like you have had to diversify. This is a classic example of that.”

The judge said Harvey had already “paid a heavy price for the mistake,” with a proceeds of crime hearing determining that Harvey must pay £72,500 within three months, or face 12 months imprisonment if he defaults.

In addition, he must pay just over £16,653 in prosecution costs within a year.

This was on top of the remedial work already carried on the land, including the specialist removal of the asbestos, which had cost around £10,000.

“That will, I suspect, result in part of your farm or buildings having to be sold,” noted the judge.

He additionally sentenced Harvey to three months in prison, suspended for two years.

Judge Carr said: “A message needs to be sent that these offences will nearly always be met with prison terms.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos