Decision on charging at Helston Fairground car park in Cornwall

3
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A hugely controversial plan to start charging at one of Cornwall’s most popular free car parks has been formally confirmed today – despite passionate pleas from local members.

A scheme to charge people to park at Helston’s Fairground car park going forward caused massive upset in the town and further afield, with 969 objections sent in to Cornwall Council and an additional petition containing 4,049 responses in opposition also handed in.

The car park is used by people visiting both the Coronation Park and boating lake opposite – including the Lakeside Café and cycle hire shop businesses, as well as events held there – plus those walking into the neighbouring Penrose Estate and trails around Loe Pool.

Cornwall Council has always maintained that the reason to start charging at the car park is to help cover the cost of maintaining the site.

Officers have said that while the authority regrades the car park surface twice a year, at a cost of £6,000 per visit, this was only temporary improvement – and although the total cost of a full surfacing is not known, the last quote for a new surface was an estimated £1 million.

The now agreed proposal was for the first hour at the car park to remain free, and then charged at band C (the cheapest band) which is currently priced at 50p for up to 30 minutes, £1.50 for one hour, £1.50 for two hours, £2 for three hours, £2.50 for four hours and £5.50 for all day (9am to 6pm) – but looks set to go up. It will also be free after 4pm.

Today (Wednesday) Cornwall Council’s cabinet members met to make a final decision.

Councillor Dan Rogerson, portfolio holder for transport, said that he had visited the Fairground car park in person last week, where he met with Cornwall councillors from the Helston and the wider South Kerrier area who shared their concerns about the move.

He also met with the South Kerrier Alliance, which manages the Coronation Park, and Cllr Rogerson said that whatever happened in the vote “it was really important to continue those conversations”.

Cllr Rogerson said that aside from maintenance costs – which he pointed out were currently being paid for by the income from Cornwall’s other car parks – there were also other issues with vehicles being left for long periods of time, or “sometimes virtually abandoned.”

The car park was described as being "in a pretty awful state." (Image: Helston Packet)

Councillor Loveday Jenkin, member for Crowan, Sithney and Wendron, spoke in a bid to change the cabinet’s view before they made a decision, and asked them to withdraw the Fairground car park from the proposals.

She pointed out that the car park had been built “on the surface of a bog”, recalling how in the past a swimming pool had been built there but within a year it had sunk and had to be closed.

“You dig this up at your peril, or you will find unintended consequences,” she said.

Cllr Jenkin also pointed out that the Fairground car park had been singled out for band C parking charges, rather than the £2 all day charge being proposed for the other 12 currently free car parks.

“I don’t think that site lends itself to being an income generating site. If you turn it into one, you will have to improve the surface significantly.

“In 2015 it was quoted as £1 million. It will be a lot more now to do anything more with it,” she said.

And she added: “I don’t think the first hour being free works, as most people will go to the walks. They will go down the Penrose Estate, maybe stop at a café.

“They’re not going to be spending just one hour there. It’s not a town centre site.”

Rory Gow, councillor for Mullion, St Keverne and the Lizard, backed up her comments, saying: “I think you really need to give some weight to the strength of feeling of the residents of Helston on this.

“It really speaks to the tenacity of the residents of Helston and the Lizard Peninsula, and wider Kerrier area, that this just is not appropriate.”

He added that local police had concerns that cars could be displaced to other parts of the town, causing access issues in emergencies.

Responding to their points, Cllr Rogerson said: “Having seen it, it’s in a pretty awful state at the moment.

“I think we probably need to be looking at regrading more, looking at the potential safety concerns. And that has a cost to it.”

He said the car park was being used in different ways, and for people who walked their dog every day the first hour being free would allow that.

For those stopping longer to use the walking trails, he suggested that people would not be doing this every day but weekly or a few times a month, and so the cost would balance out.

And for people who may be parking there to work in the town, he said perhaps the council needs to look at other products available to help them.

The meeting heard the car park had been free to use for the last 40+ years. (Image: Helston Packet)

Cllr Rogerson said a growing number of people were using the app to pay for their parking, which would allow them to extend their parking if they wished to stay longer.

However, Mike Thomas, councillor for Helston North, pointed out that this would not work for the Fairground car park, as many people used the car park to walk around Loe Pool – a distance of around seven miles – and many parts, such as at Loe Bar, had no signal so it would be impossible to add more time.

He also questioned who was parking there to work in town, saying: “It’s an incredible distance to walk to work in the town centre. Well done to those people if they are using for work.”

Cllr Thomas compared the feeling in the town as “how Arthur Dent felt in The Hitch Hiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, watching the trucks coming in to demolish his home.”

He added that it needed to be considered for reinvestment, “not just seen as a cash cow.”

Cllr Rogerson replied: “It may be that tariff C isn’t the right one long term, so we would consider that under review.”

He clarified this could be done on an annual basis, in next year’s parking order.

The proposal to charge at the Fairground car park – along with all the other elements within the Proposed Off-Street Parking Places Order 2026 – was carried.

It was not stated when parking meters would be physically introduced at the car park.

Also affecting Helston in the same vote, it was agreed to convert the Trengrouse Way car park into a long stay car park, although the extended area of the car park will remain short‑stay to encourage high turnover and support quick access trips to the town centre.

  • What do you think about the decision to now start charging at the car park? Have your say in the comments.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos