Controversial Falmouth Docks redevelopment plans have been narrowly backed after Green councillors opposed to it were told to step aside.
At meeting of the town council’s planning committee on March 16 to reconsider the application from A&P, councillors tied 3-3, leaving chairman Alan Jewell to make the casting vote to recommend approval.
The recommendation was reconsidered after some councillors asked for a fresh look, arguing that additional environmental evidence had emerged since the council first backed the plans in April last year.
But at a tense meeting on Monday the two Green Party councillors Jon Stowell and Jackie Walkden, who had already voiced concerns about the plan, were told because of this they could be seen as having pre-judged the matter and should remove themselves from the debate.
Both councillors had laide out their concerns in a Cornwall Green Party press release that was reported by the Packet.
A visualisation of proposed improvements viewed from Flushing (Image: FDEC/ Cornwall Council)
Cornwall Council’s monitoring officer found that, because of those public comments, the pair could be viewed as having pre-determined their position on the reconsidered application which could put the decision in jeopardy if challenged in the future.
However, They also considered that councillors Alan Jewell and Debra Clegg, who also voted on the original committee, would be able to come to the new committee with an open mind.
Cllr Jewell told Cllr Stowell that his comments published in the Packet were the “clearest case” of pre-determination he had ever seen.
Cllr Stowell said he had intended only to highlight environmental risks associated with the project and did not see why he should have to withdraw himself from the process. Nonetheless, both councillors ultimately agreed, Cllr Stowell reluctantly, to withdraw from the discussion.
A visualisation of proposed improvements viewed from Woodhouse Terrace (Image: FDEC/ Cornwall Council)
The redevelopment plans include modernizing existing infrastructure, building new wharves and enabling future floating offshore wind (FLOW) operations. The proposals have attracted extensive public and environmental scrutiny.
The project was originally recommended for approval by the town council in April 2025, with councillors saying the upgrades were needed to secure the docks’ long-term future.
Previous Packet reporting highlighted concerns about dredging around the wharves, including the risk of disturbing contaminated sediments and the impact on water quality.
Representatives from A&P Falmouth told councillors the dredging would be limited to areas around the wharves. They said contaminated material would be taken to licensed waste facilities outside Cornwall, while other material would be disposed of at designated sites at sea.
They said the work was needed to keep the dock’s prosperous and argued the overall redevelopment would deliver environmental improvements.
The increase in cruise ship capacity enabled by the proposed development, is estimated to generate net additional GVA (direct and supply chain) of £12.0 million per annum, and even a worst-case scenario would still generate an additional £6 million, says the company behind the project.
The redevelopment would bring in large cruise and include a site to put together floating wind farms (Image: FDEC/ Cornwall Council)
Cruise passenger projections for the proposed development estimate that up to 200,000 total passengers a year will disembark with the number of cruise ship crew also increasing in line with passenger numbers.
They said their assessment suggested around 80 vehicle movements a day during an estimated 18 months of dredging, but that this could be reduced to about 60 with careful planning.
Some councillors raised concerns about lorries carrying potentially contaminated material travelling through the town and past schools.
An environmental scientists and local fisherman warned that disturbing contaminated seabed material — including PCBs and heavy metals — and dumping “clean” waste at sea could pose risks to marine habitats and traditional shellfishing grounds within the Fal estuary.
After hearing the presentation from A&P Falmouth and submissions from the environmental scientist and a shellfish fisherman, the remaining councillors were split.
With Cllrs Stowell and Walkden having withdrawn, the six remaining committee members voted three to three on whether to maintain the council’s previous support.
The chair, Cllr Alan Jewell, then used a casting vote to back the application, on the condition that vehicle movements linked to removing dredged material (and associated construction traffic) should be kept to a minimum.
Read more
Passionate pleas as decision made on future of Helston's Fairground car park
Plea to support Cornwall NHS doctor recovering from severe stroke
Government 'holding out' on reimbursing Cornwall for £5m spent after storm 'disaster'
The committee’s updated comment will repeat the town council’s earlier reasons for supporting the scheme, while adding a request that lorry movements be managed to the lowest practicable level.
In its formal submission, Falmouth Town Council said the redevelopment aligns with policies BE1 and BE2 of the Falmouth Neighbourhood Development Plan, which incorporates the Falmouth Harbour Plan.
The proposal by Falmouth Docks and Engineering Company (FDEC) forms part of a wider £150 million programme to transform the site into a hub for cruise vessels, offshore wind assembly and expanded repair facilities.
It has been backed by the Government, and supporters say the project would safeguard jobs and modernise ageing dock structures. Critics argue the dredging and disposal of material could harm sensitive marine ecosystems in the Fal and Helford Special Area of Conservation.
Share