A packed public meeting in Falmouth has heard strong concerns over plans to redevelop and dredge the town’s docks, with warnings of potential harm to the marine environment and fishing industry.
More than 130 people gathered at Pendennis Community Centre on Wednesday evening (July 30) to hear from marine specialists, oyster fishers, and residents about the proposed £150 million Falmouth Docks redevelopment.
The scheme, put forward by Falmouth Docks and Engineering Company (FDEC) and A&P Falmouth Ltd, includes dredging parts of the Fal Estuary to increase depth around the wharves and allow larger vessels, including cruise ships, to berth alongside.
Developers say the project could bring up to 200,000 cruise passengers a year to Falmouth by 2030, boost the local economy by an estimated £13 million annually, and create more than 350 jobs.
Plans also include new wharf infrastructure and facilities to support floating offshore wind projects.
However, speakers at the meeting raised concerns about the scale and impact of dredging near a designated Special Area of Conservation (SAC).
Dr Dan Barrios-O’Neill, Head of Marine Conservation at Cornwall Wildlife Trust, said sediment data gathered for the project suggested the presence of “highly toxic chemicals”.
He told attendees: “Sediment sampling carried out in preparation for the project is wholly inadequate, lacking the resolution needed to reliably determine which areas are dangerously contaminated, and which are safe for disposal at sea.
“Right now, the data simply cannot assure us that the organisations in charge can redevelop the docks in a safe and sustainable way.”
He warned that dredging could release contaminated plumes into the estuary, potentially damaging the Carrick Roads ecosystem and local fisheries.
“The environment is the economy,” he added.
“Protecting Falmouth’s unique ecosystems also protects local businesses and tourism trade.”
Cornwall Wildlife Trust has previously submitted a “holding objection” to the Marine Management Organisation (MMO), citing concerns including contaminated sediment, underwater noise, and the potential impact on protected habitats.
Local oyster fishers and commercial fishermen at the meeting echoed those fears, arguing the plans did not sufficiently account for tidal conditions that could spread sediment through key fishing grounds.
One fisher said: “Falmouth’s oyster fishery is the last in the country that is productive.
"We have a significant heritage here that brings in local tourism, jobs, and economic benefits.
"If the dredging goes ahead, it would be a disaster for us.”
Residents also raised questions about the impact of increasing cruise tourism, with some warning of “over-tourism” and air pollution.
One attendee questioned whether expanding cruise capacity was compatible with Cornwall Council’s climate commitments, describing cruise ships as “the most environmentally damaging form of tourism”.
A community campaign group, Stop The Dredge, has been set up to raise awareness of the proposals and their potential impact.
However, supporters of the scheme argue that dredging is necessary to maintain Falmouth’s long-standing role as a working port.
Read more
Camborne visitors ban extended after ongoing anti-social behaviour concerns
Chef Adam Handling MBE condemns ‘evil’ family after chickens killed and eggs smashed
All you need to know ahead of this year's Falmouth Carnival - including how to enter
Posting on social media, Falmouth town and county councillor David Saunby said the plans involve targeted “pocket dredging” around wharves rather than dredging the entire channel.
He said: “Falmouth has always been a working port for 160 years… [dredging] was common place… to stop the wharves from silting up, so the big ships could dock alongside on a low tide.”
He added that a build-up of sediment in recent years has made it more difficult for larger vessels to berth safely.
Project representatives have also said they have worked with Natural England, Cornwall Council, and other stakeholders, with nearly £1 million invested in environmental impact assessments completed in early 2025.
Drystan Jones, A&P’s director of port development, previously said: “We are very keen that the scheme is not causing friction within the community.”
The Marine Management Organisation, designated by DEFRA as the lead environmental regulator for the project, is overseeing the marine licence process.
Further analysis of environmental data is expected in the coming weeks, while Cornwall Council’s Strategic Planning Committee is due to consider elements of the scheme on August 20.
Share