Cornwall councillor warns farm sales could shrink estate

Adrian Parsons, Cornwall councillor and farmer (Pic: Cllr Adrian Parsons / Facebook)
Adrian Parsons, Cornwall councillor and farmer (Pic: Cllr Adrian Parsons / Facebook)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.
Close Icon

Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.

Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?

What is the Public Notice Portal?

The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.

Search the Public Notice Portal

A Cornwall councillor, who also works as a farmer, believes that some of those in power at Cornwall Council are downplaying the importance of their farms estate. Cllr Adrian Parsons has raised concerns that farmhouses and agricultural buildings could be sold off quickly to balance budgets elsewhere in the authority.

The Liberal Democrat member for Altarnun and Stoke Climsland, who farms at Illand, near Launceston, also fears that if the sale of council farms continues at its current rate “there soon will not be much left”.

He has spoken out following the council’s decision to review its 10,000-acre farms estate, which will include selling some of its dairy farms, expensive-to-maintain farmhouses and other buildings. Its Lib Dem / Independent Cabinet also wants affordable houses to be built on 100 acres of the land, with plans for another 300 acres for homes in the coming years.

Cabinet discussed the council’s Farms Strategy 2019-2039 at its meeting on Wednesday, November 11 and approved a recommendation to “carefully assess each farm’s ability to meet financial targets … and remove elements of the estate that are unlikely to sufficiently contribute towards these to a satisfactory level”. It was also mentioned that some farmhouses could be turned into council-run children’s homes.

While Cllr Parsons believes that “not much will change” in the way the council runs its farms estate, he still has concerns.

He told us: “The most important point is that it should provide reassurance to our existing tenants. For them, I believe their future remains secure, with the exception perhaps of those who have fields on the edge of towns or villages where officers/portfolio holders with an eye for development may have other plans for those parcels.

“Another positive is the commitment we have been given that the core land asset of the estate, currently around 10,000 acres, will be retained throughout the lifetime of this administration.”

However, he added: “Having listened to the Cabinet debate [on November 11], what concerns me is that there are people in positions of influence who seem somewhat detached from, and are downplaying, the very ethos of what Cornwall Council farms are all about.

“While some would have you believe that the estate represents only a tiny percentage of the land available in Cornwall, it is impossible to underestimate its importance in providing new entrants with an opportunity and foothold in a sector where such opportunities are becoming increasingly difficult to find.

“My real concern with this strategy is that when farms are relinquished by existing tenants the green light has now been given for them to come under even greater scrutiny, increasing the likelihood that houses and buildings could be sold off at a faster pace if money is needed to balance budgets elsewhere.”

Cllr Parsons said: “Be mindful that, over the past three years, the number of farms let by Cornwall Council has fallen from around 85 to closer to 68 holdings. If the sale of farmhouses and buildings continues at that rate unchecked, there soon will not be much left.

“Personally, I believe the loss of the Cornwall Council Farms Committee, which was abolished when this strategy was introduced in 2019, together with the scrutiny previously provided by members who had a genuine passion for and interest in the estate, has only accelerated the situation we now find ourselves in. If this reduction in active holdings continues unchecked, it will not be long before we are told the estate is no longer viable.

“Every farm we lose is a lost opportunity for aspiring farmers to work the land. As we have seen with recent lettings, the appetite is clearly there.

“Competition is fierce and the number of applicants far exceeds the number of holdings coming to the market. Letting farms at good rental values is not a problem, and neither do I believe the estate’s viability is an issue, despite what some may suggest. The problem arises only when the estate is unable to retain all the income it generates.

“Like the rest of society, farmers require a home too and for welfare and numerous other reasons the best place for any farmer to live is on the farm, without that opportunity it only adds to the challenge of remaining viable.”

Cllr Parsons also commented on the Cabinet’s plan for housing on some of the land as part of its Homes Cornwall initiative.

“We are told that up to 400 acres of Cornwall Council farm land has been identified for potential local-needs housing development and that it is not about making money. Based on recent experience, from what I’ve seen I would probably agree.

“We have Langarth, with its impressive new road, bus stops and cycle lanes. Nearly a decade in the making and still not a single home has been delivered on site. We have the flagship Pydar regeneration scheme lying idle in the middle of Truro.

“Closer to home, we have the Cornwall Council link road site next to Pennygillam roundabout [at Launceston], where the access road opened merely to retain planning permission now looks a shambles and is no nearer to delivering homes than it was when the council acquired the site more than six years ago. It would not surprise me if that land was soon put on the open market.

“I have even seen a small council-owned site in Treburley that would have been straightforward to develop and ideal for delivering up to eight local needs affordable homes. It was considered for development, but once again it could not be made to work and was eventually sold. These are just a handful of the sites I know about. Some will be retained in the hope that they become viable in the future, while others will likely be sold at a loss like the one in Treburley.

“So, my question is this: if these sites cannot be delivered, why would the additional 400 acres now being brought into the process be any different? Unless they are in particularly high-value locations, it seems unlikely they will be. And where sites are deliverable, I suspect they will ultimately be built out by housing provider partners. If that is the case, then we are essentially just selling the land on.

“While some would like to frame this as taking land away from farming in order to provide affordable housing, I suspect the real reasons may be somewhat different, given the council’s wider financial position.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos