Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.
Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?What is the Public Notice Portal?
The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.
Search the Public Notice PortalMajor plans to redevelop Falmouth Docks have been approved despite concerns over the environmental impact of huge offshore wind turbines, cruise ships, dredging and hundreds of potential HGV movements through the town.
The decision was made by the strategic planning committee this morning (Image: Louis Greaves)
Cornwall Council's Strategic Planning Committee voted by seven votes to three, with no abstentions, to approve the scheme subject to a series of conditions.
Prior to the meeting environmental protestors from Stop the Dredge gathered outside.
The redevelopment will see eight existing buildings demolished and new wharves, walls and other infrastructure constructed as part of a major modernisation of the docks.
Members of the public watch from the public gallery (Image: Louis Greaves)
The investment is designed to allow Falmouth to handle additional cargo and larger cruise ships while providing facilities for the floating offshore wind industry.
Fully assembled floating offshore wind turbines could measure up to 229 metres to the blade tip, while specialist cranes used to construct them could reach around 140 metres.
Planning officers accepted the turbines would cause significant adverse landscape, seascape and visual impacts and affect the setting of designated heritage assets and the Cornwall National Landscape.
Protestors outside the meeting (Image: Louis Greaves)
However, they stressed the turbines would be temporary, with fully assembled units anticipated to be present for two periods of around two weeks during a ten-month period.
Officers concluded the harm was outweighed by the economic benefits of modernising the docks and the role the facility could play in offshore renewable energy.
Traffic was another major concern.
At the peak of demolition and construction, the development's environmental statement predicted up to 488 vehicle movements a day, including 354 HGV movements.
However, measures subsequently agreed with the applicant are intended to reduce the number of HGV loads by at least 25 per cent.
The docks could also handle around 11 additional Excellence-class cruise ship visits a year, with a worst-case scenario involving two such ships generating 384 additional vehicle movements in a day.
Protestors outside the meeting (Image: Louis Greaves)
During the meeting that were a number of interruptions from those opposed to the plan in the public gallery, with the chair of the committee Councillor Chris Batters warning they would be evicted if they continued, he also said he would sing the national anthem to drown them out.
Environmental concerns
Dr Tim Hughes, a senior lecturer at the University of Exeter's Centre for Environmental Mathematics and a Falmouth resident, told councillors that he did not oppose modernisation but believed more work was needed before permission was granted.
He said: "I'm not opposed to the modernisation of the docks, but there are many major issues to resolve first."
Dr Hughes raised concerns about air quality, wastewater, the disturbance of sediment and contaminants, protected habitats and greenhouse gas emissions.
Questioning the balancing exercise carried out by officers, he said: "It has underestimated or ignored these harms and overestimated the benefits or failed to acknowledge their uncertainty."
He also argued: "There has not been an adequate assessment of Scope 3 emissions and there has not been a published methodology."
A late representation from environmental organisation Opportunity Green also challenged the assessment of Scope 3 emissions.
Protestors outside the meeting (Image: Louis Greaves)
Officers maintained that the methodology used was appropriate but recommended an additional condition requiring annual carbon monitoring and management, including Scope 3 emissions.
The council's environmental health officer had not objected over the air-quality assessment and officers decided a separate air-pollution monitoring condition was not necessary.
Protestors hold up signs in the public gallery (Image: Louis Greaves)
Dredging considered separately
Proposed dredging proved one of the most contentious issues during the debate.
The council stressed that its planning decision does not grant permission for the dredging, which requires a separate marine licence from the Marine Management Organisation.
During questioning, officers also clarified that the application does not propose disposing of contaminated dredged material at sea.
Councillors scrutinised the wording of a condition which referred to maximising sea disposal and agreed that it should make clear this related to unpolluted material.
Green Party Penryn councillor Dean Evans supported investment in Falmouth Docks but urged the committee to either defer or reject the application in its current form.
He told members: "I fully support the redevelopment of the docks and the docks has been lacking in investment for many years."
However, he questioned the extent of dredging, the future requirements of floating wind turbines and arrangements for dredged material.
He said he would prefer councillors to "turn it down so the applicant can come back with a better application that just deals with the reconstruction of the docks so that Falmouth can carry on doing what it does well."
'Important for local jobs'
Other councillors concluded the economic advantages outweighed the concerns.
Cllr Laurie Magowan broadly supported the plans, having brought the application before the strategic committee because of concerns around the potential impact on highways, residents and the wider community.
He welcomed the proposed reduction in HGV movements and said the investment was needed to safeguard existing employment and create opportunities for an expanding workforce.
During the final debate, one committee member described the decision as particularly personal, having grown up in Falmouth with a father who worked at the docks before being made redundant during its decline in the late 1970s.
The councillor acknowledged there were "some very clear negatives", but said these had to be balanced against "a raft of very significant and important positives".
Another councillor, proposing approval, said: "It's important for the economy. It's important for local jobs. It's important for Cornwall. And in fact, it's important for the UK."
However, one of the three councillors voting against the plans remained particularly concerned by the proposal to bring bigger cruise ships alongside.
They said: "Cruise ships are not environmentally friendly vessels. They are polluting vessels."
They added: "As that is part of the application, I cannot support the application as it stands today."
Protestors outside the meeting (Image: Louis Greaves)
As part of the approval, councillors also agreed that advance notification of scheduled cruise ship arrivals should be provided to Falmouth Town Council so the information can be shared with relevant organisations.
'Important milestone'
Following the decision, Balaena welcomed the approval and said it would now examine the conditions and work with Cornwall Council on the next stages.
Simon Gillett, chief executive of Balaena Group, said: "We welcome the committee's decision and the opportunity to move these proposals forward responsibly.
"Falmouth Docks supports skilled employment, apprenticeships and a network of local suppliers and businesses. Our ambition is to build on that contribution, giving future generations the opportunity to develop their skills and pursue rewarding maritime careers here in Cornwall."
Mr Gillett said the company would work with the council and other authorities to address the conditions and pledged to continue engaging with the community.
He added: "We recognise how much the harbour and its marine environment mean to Falmouth. Environmental responsibility must remain central to the development, and we take seriously our obligation to meet the requirements of the planning and marine licensing processes.
"Today's decision is an important milestone. Our focus now is on the detailed work needed to progress the development with care, supporting Falmouth's maritime future and the community around it."
Balaena said its priorities included long-term employment, apprenticeships and creating opportunities for local firms through investment in the docks.
The company's statement also stressed that Thursday's planning decision does not authorise the proposed dredging, which remains subject to the separate Marine Management Organisation licensing process.
Share