Falmouth campaigners seek action after plastic bead spill

Bi0-beads similar to these escaped into the Fal Estuary in 2016 <i>(Image: Submitted)</i>
Bi0-beads similar to these escaped into the Fal Estuary in 2016 (Image: Submitted)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Campaigners in Falmouth are calling for urgent action over plastic pollution after fresh information emerged about a major bio-bead spill into the Fal Estuary.

Plastic Free Falmouth has joined community groups across southern England in warning about the continued use of the small plastic pellets at wastewater treatment works.

The renewed concern comes 16 years after bio-beads escaped from South West Water's Newham wastewater treatment works in Truro.

Community campaigners say around 5.4 billion beads were lost and that millions remain in the Fal Estuary.

South West Water has now confirmed there was a "partial discharge" of bio-beads from Newham in 2010 after containment mesh within the treatment process deteriorated.

However, the company said it does not have a verified figure for how many beads escaped.

It said: "Following the incident, the damaged mesh was replaced and measures were introduced to prevent further bio-beads escaping from the treatment process."

New information obtained by campaigners has also shed further light on how the Environment Agency dealt with the incident.

Emma O’Neill, of Plastic Free Falmouth, said: "There is no effective Environment Agency oversight of pellet management.

"We found there was no EA investigation or enforcement action from this spill. Water companies are left to set and monitor their own standards, and face few consequences for bio-bead spills."

The Environment Agency has disputed the suggestion there was no regulatory response, saying officers attended and worked with South West Water following the incident.

However, it confirmed the event was recorded as a non-compliance with the permit at Newham rather than as a pollution incident.

An Environment Agency spokesperson said: "We responded to an incident at Newham Sewage Treatment Works in 2010 and worked to ensure South West Water made changes to prevent any reoccurrence, including a significant upgrade to the site.

"Were this incident to happen again today, we would apply an even stronger approach, as we have done with other incidents around the country."

The agency said different processes were in place in 2010 and incidents involving microplastics had not previously been experienced by its officers.

Changes following the incident included the eventual decommissioning of Newham Sewage Treatment Works and its replacement with a new upgraded site, alongside new requirements for South West Water to improve the maintenance and upkeep of sites using bio-beads.

The Environment Agency said that, with those measures satisfactorily in place, it did not take further enforcement action at the time.

Bio-beads are small plastic pellets used as part of the treatment process at some sewage works.

Campaigners say they can remain in rivers and the marine environment for decades after escaping.

South West Water has confirmed that eight of its 655 wastewater treatment works still use bio-beads.

It said all sites using them have multiple containment measures which are regularly inspected and maintained, including secondary containment mesh.

The company said replacing bio-bead treatment requires significant investment because it involves changing the wider treatment process.

It added that opportunities to remove bio-beads would be considered as sites are upgraded, but confirmed there is currently no timetable for their complete removal.

South West Water said: "We take our environmental responsibilities seriously and continue to monitor, maintain and improve our assets to minimise the risk of bio-beads entering the environment."

The renewed warning from Falmouth comes as other coastal communities report continuing problems with the pellets.

A new incident involving bio-beads at Honiton in Devon is being investigated by the Environment Agency, while communities have also raised concerns following pollution at Camber Sands in East Sussex and the discovery of beads around Charmouth in Dorset.

The Environment Agency said it now responds differently to such incidents, pointing to Camber Sands, where an investigation remains ongoing.

Plastic Free Falmouth and other community groups are calling for greater regulation of bio-beads, more transparency from water companies and a clear timetable for moving away from treatment systems which use the plastic pellets.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos