Stop the Dredge response to Falmouth Docks planning decision

3
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.
Close Icon

Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.

Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?

What is the Public Notice Portal?

The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.

Search the Public Notice Portal

Environmental campaigners from Stop the Dredge have voiced disappointment after councillors backed plans to expand Falmouth Docks.

Cornwall Council’s Strategic Planning Committee approved the controversial proposals - which would include extensive dredging and dock upgrades - during a meeting on Thursday at Lys Kernow.

The redevelopment will see eight existing buildings demolished and new wharves, walls and other infrastructure constructed as part of a major modernisation of the docks.

The investment is designed to allow Falmouth to handle additional cargo and larger cruise ships while providing facilities for the floating offshore wind industry.

Fully assembled floating offshore wind turbines could measure up to 229 metres to the blade tip, while specialist cranes used to construct them could reach around 140 metres.

You can read more about the proposals and the planning decision here:

Campaigners - who carried out a protest before the start of the meeting - say the scheme poses serious risks to the marine environment, air quality and the health and wellbeing of the community.

Speaking after the meeting, Fay Locke, of the Stop the Dredge group, said: "We’re obviously disappointed that the committee has failed to take on board the very detailed evidence showing why these plans could do so much damage.

"But this is very far from being the end of the story.

"The Marine Management Organisation has still not approved the dredge that is the most damaging aspect of the scheme.

"We hope that it will bear in mind its statutory duty to protect the marine environment, and the extensive expert evidence warning of the dangers of the dredge being carried out as proposed.

"We’ve been advised that the many serious flaws in the developers’ application may give strong grounds for a legal challenge. We hope it does not have to come to that."

Campaigners are concerned about the environmental impact of the development at Falmouth Docks (Image: Louis Greaves/Falmouth Packet)

Dr Tim Hughes, an environmental data scientist, addressed the committee, highlighting what he described as “serious issues and omissions” in the application.

Dr Hughes said: "We all want to see the docks modernised, but it’s vital that this is done in a responsible way.

"Our view, supported by extensive scientific and technical research, is that it was only able to do this by significantly underweighting or, in some cases entirely ignoring, these harms – not least in terms of air pollution from cruise ships running their engines in port, greenhouse gas emissions, adverse effects on protected natural habitats and damage to the local fishing and tourism industries."

Green Party councillor Dean Evans, who represents Falmouth Boslowick, also raised concerns.

Cllr Evans said: "A large part of the rationale for the development as proposed was that it is needed to accommodate large floating offshore wind (FLOW) installations.

"But there is little chance that Falmouth will benefit from major contracts for wind turbine assembly.

"There are bigger, better-placed docks at Bristol and Milford Haven."

He also warned that one of the planning conditions could actually result in greater harm to the marine environment.

This states that there should be a 25 per cent reduction in the volume of dredge spoil removed through the centre of Falmouth in HGVs, to mitigate the increase in traffic congestion.

Cllr Evans said: "While reducing traffic on our congested roads is welcome, the problem is that this could incentivise the contractor to dispose of even larger quantities of spoil at sea, just outside the Falmouth Bay to St Austell Bay Special Protection Area (SPA).

"As Cornwall Wildlife Trust and others have pointed out, much of the material to be dredged is known to contain high levels of toxic chemicals, and inadequate sampling proposals already increase the risk of highly toxic spoil being dumped at sea, with serious impacts on marine organisms and ecosystems."

Environmental campaigners protesting outside Lys Kernow/County Hall on Thursday ahead of a planning decision meeting (Image: Louis Greaves/Falmouth Packet)

Balaena Group, the developer behind the scheme, welcomed the planning approval.

Simon Gillett, chief executive of Balaena Group, said: "We welcome the committee’s decision and the opportunity to move these proposals forward responsibly.

"Falmouth Docks supports skilled employment, apprenticeships and a network of local suppliers and businesses.

"Our ambition is to build on that contribution, giving future generations the opportunity to develop their skills and pursue rewarding maritime careers here in Cornwall."

He stressed the company’s commitment to environmental responsibility.

Mr Gillett said: "We recognise how much the harbour and its marine environment mean to Falmouth.

"Environmental responsibility must remain central to the development, and we take seriously our obligation to meet the requirements of the planning and marine licensing processes."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos